Everton have been deducted ten points after being found guilty of breaching the Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules (PSRs).
The sanction, which was announced on Friday and came into effect immediately, was imposed by an independent commission following a disciplinary hearing last month. The Premier League referred Everton to the commission in March for an alleged breach of its PSRs in the three-year period up to 2021/22.
In a statement, the Premier League said: “During the proceedings, the Club admitted it was in breach of the PSRs for the period ending zeason 2021/22 but the extent of the breach remained in dispute.
“Following a five-day hearing last month, the Commission determined that Everton FC’s PSR Calculation for the relevant period resulted in a loss of £124.5 million, as contended by the Premier League, which exceeded the threshold of £105 million permitted under the PSRs.”
Everton have said they will appeal the punishment, which has seen them fall from 14th in the table to 19th. A club statement said it “believes that the Commission has imposed a wholly disproportionate and unjust sporting sanction.”
Interest on stadium loans
A key part of the case centred on interest payable on loans to build Everton’s new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock.
While those were allowed to be factored into the club’s accounts for the 2020/21 financial year, the Premier League disputed that they were permissible a year later and, as detailed in the commission’s report, said: “Everton submitted misleading information about the stadium financing costs.”
Other aspects covered during the hearing included the impact of Covid-19, transfer levies and the inability to sell a player referred to as “Player X” because of a unique set of circumstances.
Compensation claim ‘could lead to further nine-point penalty’
Meanwhile, The Daily Mail has claimed that Everton could be forced into administration and given an additional nine-point penalty if a second independent commission rules that other clubs should be compensated for their spending breaches.
According to the newspaper, Burnley, Leeds United and Leicester City are pressing ahead with plans to bring a compensation claim against Everton after the club was found guilty of the PSR breaches.
It is understood that Everton's prospective new owner 777 Partners has committed to providing around £20 million a month to help with the club's running costs whilst the Premier League are assessing its takeover bid, but would not be willing to pay a compensation bill that could run into tens of millions of pounds.
Everton's current regime lack the funds to settle a significant compensation bill, which would leave the club facing administration and the automatic nine-point penalty introduced by the Premier League in 2004.
Paris Saint-Germain owner close to selling minority stake but ‘remains committed to club’
Paris Saint-Germain owner Qatar Sports Investment (QSI) is set to sell a minority stake in the club, The Athletic reports.
PSG’s chief revenue officer Marc Armstrong confirmed that talks are underway over a deal but insisted that QSI remains fully committed to the club and does not have plans to exit or cede majority control.
“We have no interest in selling the club, this will definitely be a minority stake,” Armstrong said.
He added: “The ownership are more committed to the club than ever, which can be seen by the money we have spent on Poissy [PSG’s new training ground, which opened this year] and what we are prepared to spend on the [Parc des Princes] stadium: those are both long-term investments.”
American private equity group Arctos Partners appears likeliest to invest in the French champions. Back in August, it was reported that the club’s president Nasser Al-Khelaïfi had met with senior executives from Arctos to discuss the acquisition of a stake which was expected to be between 5 and 15 per cent.
Stakes across multiple sports
Arctos has already acquired shareholdings in teams across multiple sports, including in football, as well as basketball and baseball. The firm holds a stake in Liverpool owner Fenway Sports Group, while it acquired a £29.2 million stake in Italian club Atalanta in May 2022.
Should a deal for PSG progress it is unclear what per cent would be sold, but the club expect it to value them above €4 billion.
Premier League's top clubs to receive larger share of prize money
The Premier League's top clubs are poised to receive a larger share of prize money starting from the 2025/26 season, as tensions rise following Everton's 10-point deduction for spending breaches.
According to the Telegraph, the merit-based system will shift from a 1.6 to one ratio to a 1.8 to one ratio, potentially increasing earnings by tens of millions for the biggest clubs.
This recalibration is influenced by international revenue growth and the Consumer Prices Index. Despite higher inflation rates benefiting smaller clubs next season, the long-term trend favors larger clubs, which has been a point of contention among Premier League members.
As clubs prepare to vote on the New Deal For Football, discussions are expected regarding how costs will be distributed among them. The deal aims to provide an additional £130 million per year to lower leagues, but the exact cost-sharing remains debated.
Spending cap
The pressure on the Premier League has intensified after Everton's punishment and subsequent calls for quicker implementation of a new independent regulator in English football.
The New Deal For Football represents a significant financial overhaul, with years of negotiation leading to broad support despite some reservations. The EFL is set to receive a substantial funding increase, while relegated teams will be allowed to spend up to 85 per cent of revenue on wages and transfers. Championship teams will face a 70 per cent spending cap but will benefit from increased solidarity payments and an "equity top-up" estimated at an additional 20 per cent of spending.
Lyon appoint L’Equipe boss Laurent Prud’homme as new CEO
Laurent Prud’homme is to become the new chief executive at Lyon after stepping down from his role at the French sports media outlet L’Equipe.
The Amaury group, which owns L’Equipe, announced Prud’homme’s departure as CEO on Friday. It is understood that Lyon owner John Textor convinced him to take up the role at the Ligue 1 club after being engaged in talks for several weeks.
Prud’homme will replace Santiago Cucci, who has been serving as Lyon’s interim CEO since July. General manager Thierry Sauvage is also departing as part of a restructure at the club.
Warner Bros. Discovery role
Prud’homme, who will take up his new role at Lyon in the coming weeks, was CEO at L’Equipe for almost three years. Prior to that, he was senior vice-president and general manager for France at Warner Bros. Discovery, including Eurosport France, for 20 years.
The outgoing L’Equipe CEO was chosen by Textor because of his knowledge of the main players in French sport, including the leaders of the FFF and the LFP. He also has a history with Lyon, the city where part of his family is from and where he completed his studies.
Prud'homme is joining Lyon at a difficult time for the club, who are currently bottom of Ligue 1 and last month announced a loss of €99 million for the 2022/23 financial year.
Real Betis return to profitability after Covid losses
Real Betis have reported a small profit of €0.17 million for the year ending 30th June, 2023, their first surplus since the Covid-19 pandemic.
The result follows a loss of €39.5 million the previous year and was achieved thanks to significant increases in revenue and a reduction in the club’s wage bill.
Turnover reached €148.7 million, up from €120.2 million in 2021/22. Last season, Real Betis finished in sixth place in LaLiga and reached the last 16 of the Europa League, after ending the season in fifth place and reaching the same stage of the Europa League in 2021/22.
Matchday income for 2022/23 rose to €24.9 million, compared with €20.1 million in 2021/22, while broadcast revenues amounted to €92.6 million, up from €84.1 million, with UEFA media rights income totalling €21.2 million, an increase from €17.6 million.
Commercial income almost doubled, from €15.9 million to €31.2 million, as did the profit from player sales, which rose from €7 million to €13.8 million.
Wage bill falls to €94.6 million
Real Betis also reduced their salary costs in 2022/23, with the club’s total wage bill falling to €94.6 million, down from €99.8 million the previous year.
For 2023/24, the club has forecast record revenues of €188 million and a profit of €4.6 million as it anticipates further increases across its key income streams.
Luis Rubiales given three-year ban by Spain's Administrative Sports Court
Spain's Administrative Sports Court (TAD) has banned the former Spanish Football Federation (RFEF) president Luis Rubiales from all football-related activities in the country for three years.
As reported by Spanish media, the suspension, which disqualifies Rubiales from holding any position in Spanish sport, has been imposed as a result of two proposed sanctions, each for bans of one year and a half following his actions at the Women's World Cup final in Sydney in August.
One was for an abuse of authority when he kissed Jenni Hermoso at the medal ceremony, and the other for the touching of his genitals during celebrations while standing next to members of the Spanish royal family.
When it opened its case against Rubiales in September, TAD adjudged that Rubiales’ behaviour constituted a “serious” breach of conduct, but not “very serious”, which would have given the Spanish government the option of removing him from his post immediately.
Rubiales to appeal decision
According to Spanish media, Rubiales will appeal TAD’s ruling, which is independent of FIFA’s decision to ban the former RFEF president from all football-related activities at national and international level, also for three years.
FIFA announced last month that its Disciplinary Committee had found that Rubiales acted in breach of article 13 of the FIFA Disciplinary Code, which relates to offensive behaviour and violations of the principles of fair play.
Rubiales has already begun an appeal against the FIFA ban. He eventually stepped down as RFEF president on 10th September, but argued he was the victim of a "disproportionate campaign" and "excessive persecution."