Tuesday briefing: Manchester City claim Premier League analysis of commercial income is ‘unfair’
Tuesday briefing: Manchester City claim Premier League analysis of commercial income is ‘unfair’
IMAGO
UEFA allows Manchester clubs to compete alongside sister teams in Europe
Eintracht Frankfurt CEO Axel Hellmann issues warning over failed Bundesliga media rights deals
Nottingham Forest set to stay at City Ground after agreeing to purchase stadium land
9 July 2024 - 4:30 AM
Manchester City are reportedly claiming that the Premier League has treated them unfairly in assessing their commercial income by relying on the analysis of a data company that also works for their rivals.
As reported by The Guardian, the league’s scrutiny of the fair market value of City’s deals was undertaken by the global data and media valuation firm Nielsen Sports, which has contracts with several top-flight clubs.
City are understood to have raised the Premier League’s use of Nielsen in their legal battle over associated party transactions (APT), which was heard in private last month. A decision on the landmark case is expected soon, although it is unclear when it will be made public.
Competition law
It is claimed by City that the APT rules are unlawful because they contravene competition law. If successful, the club will demand financial damages from the Premier League for perceived losses from sponsorship deals blocked after analysis by Nielsen.
The Guardian also reported that City are understood to be arguing the Premier League’s APT rules are far more restrictive than UEFA’s and want them relaxed.
UEFA allows Manchester clubs to compete alongside sister teams in Europe
UEFA has ruled that Manchester United and Manchester City can compete in the same European competitions as other clubs under the same ownership next season.
United and Nice, the Ligue 1 club owned by Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s company INEOS, have both qualified for the Europa League, while City are in the Champions League along with LaLiga side Girona, who are also part of City Football Group.
UEFA had launched proceedings over potential conflicts regarding those clubs after relaxing its rules on multi-club ownership groups ahead of next season’s changes to its club competitions.
“Significant changes”
In a statement on Friday, UEFA said that “following the implementation of significant changes by the concerned investors” in both Nice and Girona, no one has “control or decisive influence” over both teams.
Girona confirmed changes to its board last week, while UEFA said that in both instances, the respective clubs “will not transfer players to each other, whether permanently or on loan, directly or indirectly, from July 2024 until September 2025, with the exception of pre-existing transfer agreements”.
Eintracht Frankfurt CEO Axel Hellmann issues warning over failed Bundesliga media rights deals
Axel Hellmann, the Eintracht Frankfurt CEO and a member of the DFL executive committee, has warned that the Bundesliga is facing a serious fallout from a potentially delayed or failed sale of its broadcast rights.
In comments reported by Bloomberg, Hellmann said: “Should we not be able to enforce our prices, should there be a decline in broadcasting proceeds, German clubs will have difficulties maintaining their status.”
Back in April, the DFL was forced to suspend the auction process for its domestic broadcast rights running from 2025/26 to 2028/29 after DAZN claimed it had unlawfully awarded the deal for the largest bundle of games to rival Sky.
European Super League risk
Plans to sell a stake in the DFL’s Bundesliga’s media rights business to a private equity firm have failed twice in the past two years, additionally undercutting the league’s ability to develop its streaming strategy.
“That’s why we have to build our own media management platform,” Hellman said, adding that if the league fails to address these issues, there is still a risk a European Super League could potentially destroy the current system of national leagues.
Nottingham Forest set to stay at City Ground after agreeing to purchase stadium land
Nottingham Forest look set to stay at the City Ground after Nottingham City Council confirmed that an agreement in principle is in place for the club to purchase the freehold of thestadium’s land, ending months of stalemate on its future.
At a meeting yesterday, Labour Council Leader Neghat Khan announced that a deal was in place, although it is yet to be officially ratified. An official decision on the deal is set for 16th July.
The exact terms of the agreement have not been confirmed, but The Athletic reported in May that the site had been valued at between £8-10 million.
Expand capacity to 40,000
A fresh agreement is seen as critical for the club’s existing plans to redevelop the stadium, which would expand its capacity from 29,000 to 40,000 through the rebuilding of the Peter Taylor Stand and extension of the Bridgford stand.
Previous negotiations over a leasehold agreement for the City Ground had broken down over the amount of money the club was prepared to pay, leading Forest to say they were considering a potential move to Toton in Nottinghamshire to create a new 50,000-capacity stadium.